Jump to content



Toggle %s Hello Guest

Hello!

If this is your first visit, we invite you to register (click here) for full user access. Membership is free but is required in order to post to our forums. Membership entitles you to a discount on Native Watercraft Accessories purchased through the forum host, Get:Outdoors. Please read over guidelines and rules on the use of the forum here (Click Here)


Thank you.
Welcome Guest Messages 6.0.0 © 2018 VirteQ

Photo
- - - - -

Marvel 10 vs. 12


  • Please log in to reply
4 replies to this topic

#1 dekemiller

dekemiller

    Junior Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 3 posts

Posted 27 February 2012 - 07:46 AM

I own a Magic 12 and am looking for a sit-in. A local store has a bunch of Native Watercraft Marvel 10s and 12s. I am looking to do some fitness kayaking involving some distance. Does anyone know if there is a speed difference between the 10 and the 12? Both are the same width and I know the extra length of the 12 will help it track a little straighter but how about speed? Does the extra length of the 12 help, hurt, or make any difference at all?

#2 boykinsbuddy

boykinsbuddy

    Super Moderator

  • Moderators
  • 1,489 posts

Posted 27 February 2012 - 08:43 AM

The 12 will definitely be faster. The longer the hull taking into consideration the width and hull shape, the faster it will be.

#3 NOG Admin

NOG Admin

    Administrator

  • Administrators
  • 4,047 posts

Posted 27 February 2012 - 02:09 PM

In my mind fitness training in a kayak would involve at minimum a touring boat. The Inuit series has been shifted over to Liquid Logic, along with the Marvels, but can be seen here http://www.liquidlog...aks.com/rec.cfm. I used to do a fair amount of touring, covering good distances so if that is your goal a tourer like the Inuit would be more ideal than a Marvel.
-Philip

#4 dekemiller

dekemiller

    Junior Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 3 posts

Posted 02 March 2012 - 05:50 PM

Sorry for the delay. I spent a bunch of time researching speeds relative to boat dimensions (width, depth, length) and discovered that "hull speed" (from what I read the speed at which the boat starts to surf its own wave) is directly proportional to the length of the boat (actually proportional to the "water line": the length of the boat and "water line" can be quite different depending on the design of the hull). If I did the calculations correctly, the Marvel 12 should have a hull speed at least 25% higher than the 10. In the end, I am not trying to cover great distances, just more distance in the time I have allotted on my outings. I do a lot of "one-ways" where my wife and I drop a car at one place and then she drops me of with my boat elsewhere. As there are not a infinite number of put-in and take-out spots, I have found that a few of my combinations are a bit far in a typical 2 hour paddle in my other boats (and some of the other combinations are too close and are finished in too little time). Alas the problem I have with touring boats are the seats. I am not very flexible at the core (because of some skeletal limitations) and find that I need a very firm and rather high-backed seat. To date the only kayaks to fit the bill are the Magic 12 (my first boat with a "chair") and a bunch of boats with fixed, high-backed seats: my 2 Jackson Kayak rec boats (Regal and Riviera) as well as a few older boats I have by Dimension (Sandpiper/Cricket, Mayfly tandem), and Old Town Kayak (H2Yo). Almost all are SOT (except the Regal but it is really a SOT with a higher deck: can't even take a skirt) with very short water lines (for instance 3 of the boats are 11'4" but have water lines just under 9 feet). I love the seat in my Magic 12 (which I just got a few weeks back new: yeah, I know, hard to believe I found one new but I did in the back of someone's warehouse). I tried the Intuit but the seat back is too low and not firm enough for me. I am a high-angle paddler that puts a lot of pressure on the seat and foot bracings because of my style (think Hawaiian style ala Hawaii 5-0 but in a kayak) and the only sit-in kayak that seems to meet my seating requirements so far that I can see is the Marvel (or the Jackson Ibis but I do not really like the Jackson removable seat and the Ibis has an odd foot area). FYI, besides my day job (the one that actually pays the bills), I moonlight 2 or 3 nights a week as a kayak tour guide for a local kayak company where everyone uses tour boats: I keep up in my SOTs (actually more than keeping up: I'm usually the one in front pushing the pace). However, I have noticed that my boat is definitely surfing at the speeds we go while theirs appear to be just cruzin' (I just learned researching all this that that means I am reaching the boat's hull speed). In truth my wife recently got a Perception Sport Swiftwater 10.5 and I got a demonstration of boat length and speed. Her boat's water line is the same as the boat length (given its hull design) and combined with the hard chines in the hull, suddenly she started to keep up more when I am in boats with shorter water lines (where I was always having to slow down a lot for us to stay together). She was able to go a little faster still in the Magic 12 (which surprised me because the flatness of the bottom of the boat I thought should have made it slower but it was on calm water it is definitely the fastest in my fleet). All-in-all, I love my Magic and am sad to realize they are no longer made. Would have loved to have gotten a Magic 14.5 (to use both as a solo and as a tandem).

#5 dekemiller

dekemiller

    Junior Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 3 posts

Posted 24 March 2012 - 12:45 PM

Well I ended up with a 14.5 Inuit (one of the last ones still branded Native Watercraft as the new ones are now branded Liquidlogic). I wrote it off without giving it a chance (assumed it was as bad as other touring boats I had used). Did not realize the seat back was adjustable when I looked at it and tried it once before (and the person at the store did not point it out: most likely did not even know). Even the Liquidlogic website does not mention this adjustability: I discovered it when I saw a 2011 Native Watercraft brochure. They are now clearing out the Native Watercraft branded Marvels but they still a 12.5 Inuit and I thinbk my wife wants it.




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users